Friday, June 6, 2008
Aquila vs. Shaquill R.
Both debaters know how to project their voices. This was helpful but to the qualities of a good argument need to be maintained. Remember to clearly state reason, support with evidence, and explain how evidence supports reasoning. I really loved Aquila's rebudle as well.
Lizzy vs. Sam
What a great debate! And, kudos to the class for providing meaningful critiques! Sam's use of Lizzy's evidence and arguments and strong opening argument made for a rich and analytical debate.
Lakisha vs. Nataly
I thought that this was a good debate. Even though Lakisha took the win in the end, I felt as though both debaters did a good job. But I had no idea that Lakisha was such a good debater.
Tuesday, June 3, 2008
Mr. brasof vs. Ms. Mahdi
I really loved Ms. Mahdi's opening and her rebudle as well because not only stated her complaints about slavery but also included a picture making statement reguarding ''mothers'' in general. Mr. Brasof also had a goo opening speech. He to me got his point across in a short sweet way,(nice and smooth). His rebudle way good to because he stated his reason's why he won and then stated why she shouldn't win while throwing in a piece of her intro speech.
Brittany vs. Thomas
I really liked this debate because i have nothing bad to say about either one of them i really liked Brittany's rebudle and her cross examination it was very good.Thomas I really liked his opening speech. He to me really got his point across. So in the end this was a draw.
Naasir vs. Marcus
I really found this debate to be sort of humorous because they were going back and forth with questions and I saw plenty of openings. I really liked Naasir's opening and his rebudle. I really liked the way Marcus cross examined him and he was stuck because he had no proof and was unorganized.
Marcus vs. Amber
I really liked marcus opening speech and his rebudle. Amber i really liked the way shen she was cross examing him she had him stuck for a momment because he had to search for what he was saying then really didn't come up with any proof.
Dyniesha vs. I
I felt as though she did win that debate because of two reasons one she came stronger than i did and twon she cross examined me pretty well. I feel as though I could've projected my voice a little more I think that the judges would've gotten my point that I was trying to get across.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)